After yesterday’s blog and the wonderful comments that came as a result, I decided to continue this conversation from another front. My goal at the end of this week is to take all of the comments and thoughts from now and write a response to what I feel has been said and where I feel things are. But today I want to take the conversation a bit further. There are many thoughts as to why people don’t listen to CCM. I also believe that it is possible that we throw a whole lot of music under the umbrella of CCM that may not fit there, but that’s another thought entirely. But taking the worship side of CCM and not so much the pop side of CCM a question comes to mind. If we aren’t spending time listening to this music outside of Sunday, and non-Christians wouldn’t even know to listen to this music at all, who in the world knows the songs that we are singing on Sunday morning?
Now I will make it plain now that I’m asking this question from the worship leader position. From a position that looks out on Sunday morning and asks people to sing along with a song that they quite possibly have never heard. And because they have never heard it, they spend the whole 4 minutes staring at the screen and then looking at you as if your face is covered with remnants of Lady Gaga’s meat dress. And before I go on, yes, people stare at me like that on a weekly basis. But back to the question. Am I to gather that most of the people out in the congregation have no idea what I’m singing? Let’s take into account that there are songs that have been sung for a few years or that is in a heavy rotation in your worship team’s list of songs. Let’s also take into account that I as a worship leader am always listening for music that can be sung in my worship service on Sunday mornings. But should I stop patronizing people by say things like, “I know some of you may not have heard this song before…” knowing that it’s highly possible that no one has actually heard it before?
I think there is even a deeper question or concern that has surfaced as well. If we say that we don’t really listen to CCM or worship music or whatever we want to call it during the week for WHATEVER reason, we are saying that this music is not worth our time and it doesn’t deserve the energy we give to listening to music. If that is truly the case, then I have a couple questions. Why do we listen to and sing and even lead others in singing it on Sunday? What are we expecting during the Sunday morning worship time? What are we inviting non-believers to? Are we saying that, for instance, “Your Grace is Enough” is a good thought for Sunday morning but not really something to listen to or dwell on during the week?
I want to tread lightly even I blow through all of these thoughts. But I know a big problem that we have today with Christian music is the relevancy to the rest of the world. I will agree that we have created a wall in the way Christian music is portrayed and marketed and broadcasted. However, I feel that even in today’s world there is still relevancy in the music that Christian musicians write. I tend to believe that we as Christians are diminishing the relevancy of Christian music for the sake of trying to connect with the rest of the world. We are treating Christian music like that drunk uncle at the wedding. We all know who he is and see that he is there, but we don’t really want to introduce anyone to him because he might say something to embarrass us or offend our friends. Maybe without trying to, we are sort of saying that Christian music has NO validity to the rest of the world therefore we won’t present it to anyone and we won’t listen to it ourselves. Could it be…could it POSSIBLY be…that in trying to be relevant to the rest of the world we are further creating a disconnect between the world and Christ? I mean, we’re saying, “we want to love on you like Christ would love on you and invite you into this life and relationship, but we won’t share the stuff that goes along with it.”
Again, let me reiterate that I agree that some of the Christian music today is not the best out there, but I put it in the same category as some other music that I don’t like. I mean, I listen to, say, Kerrie Roberts as much as I listen to Taylor Swift. Not much. That’s not because Kerrie Roberts music message is cheesy and is sung through a ‘filter’ that doesn’t portray the world as it is today. I think they both have something to say. And I think they both say that pretty well. I just look for that to be said in a different way.
To try and bring all this back to the subject for today, I kinda feel that we are selling our churches short by only connecting with the music once a week. We are saying that our Sunday morning music is good for Sunday but not really good for any other time. If that’s the case, then why even sing it then? Why are we inviting people to come be a part of what our church is doing? Are we asking them to connect with the Word but not the music because it’s not really good enough to connect with during the week? I know I’ve swung the pendulum out real far, but I think it needs to be put way out there so we can talk it back. So let’s talk it back. Ready……GO!